Andrea Mitchell these days is ultra-busy disseminating comments on NBC Nightly News, MSNBC, CNBC and other programs in the broadcast family owned by parent General Electric Co.
While her official title is NBC chief foreign affairs correspondent, she has been active wearing another hat --- as a national political reporter, including being on scene at the recent GOP and Democrat conventions, notes Grumpy Editor.
In the past few days she has been dishing out commentaries on the financial market bailout which started with faulty loans, including sub-prime mortgages that have led to the current credit crisis.
The big question is: Should Andrea Mitchell be discussing these financial elements that are shaking up the U.S., since her husband, Alan Greenspan, is the former Federal Reserve Board chairman, at the helm when some of the seeds of the current meltdown were planted?
Thus, should a disclaimer appear when she goes on camera to discuss the financial situation, especially when comments or interviews are linked to the Fed? Or should NBC just bring in other talent and put Mitchell strictly on the foreign affairs beat?
Megan Garber, a staff writer at Columbia Journalism Review, gets into this with “The Elephant in the Control Room.”
Garber points out that “Greenspan, by virtue of his nearly nineteen-year chairmanship of the Federal Reserve Board, is, to some extent, culpable in the crisis we’re facing. Critics have accused the Greenspan-led Fed of inflating the housing bubble by keeping loan rates too low for too long, encouraging reckless lending and borrowing.”
Then she adds, “The degree of Greenspan’s culpability in the current meltdown is certainly debatable. One could argue, as he does, that its root cause wasn’t the interest rates of the mortgages themselves, but their repackaging. What isn’t debatable, though, is the fact that, as chairman of the body that presided over the economy while it began its slow-before-sudden descent into Dante-economic hell, the legacy of Greenspan’s Fed chairmanship is intimately entwined in the crisis.”
Garber points out, “It’s one thing for Mitchell to report the facts of the credit crisis, but venturing into commentary is a precarious trek” as is reporting on the Fed itself, which she did in a CNBC segment this week when the Fed agreed to lend American International Group Inc. (AIG) $85 billion to stave off a financial crisis.
Grumpy Editor’s end-of-week leftover notes:
Leading the “Best Cover” finalists, selected by the American Society of Magazine Editors, is New York magazine, with six nominations, followed by The New Yorker with four and Wired with three. Winners will be announced on Oct. 6…With a mountain of news developments during the week, most media missed marking Sept. 24. What was it? For those confused over a comma vs. a semicolon, it was National Punctuation Day… No calendar at the ad agency? As autumn was ushered in this week, a national Home Depot radio spot pitched tools --- for Father’s Day, nine months away... New York photographer Bert Stern is suing two others over Marilyn Monroe images he says were shot in July, 1962 in Los Angeles. Stern is seeking the photos, or at least $700,000 in repayment, plus $1 million in punitive damages and legal fees…The Baltimore Sun is starting to share video and content with WJZ, the local CBS-TV affiliate…The Boston Globe on Thursday debuted OT (Our Town/Our Teams) a 24-page, full-color, oversize tabloid weekly (initial press run: 20,000 copies) with coverage of professional sports teams…The Providence (R.I.) Journal is cutting all part timers in the news department plus five full-time positions. Oct. 10 is their last day…Some blushing at BusinessWeek: In a ranking of “50 employers with the right stuff,” it placed the failed investment banking firm Lehman Brothers at No. 29 on the list, up two places from last year…A Citibank ad this week pitched a six-month CD at 4.00 percent APY. Sounds like a great deal. But the fine print (readable with a magnifying glass) noted a checking account is required to open the CD and “fees may apply to the checking account.”