AP story on U.S. receding height raises questions
Getting wide print and broadcast play yesterday was a story claiming America is losing its "tallest country in the world" title as the growth rate in height is ebbing. Grumpy Editor finds the rambling Associated Press piece by Matt Crenson rather strange on several counts with apparently no editors raising eyebrows.
• First, a bit of editorializing in the third paragraph: “But just as it has in so many areas, America’s predominance in height has faded.”
• Then, the source of the lofty information comes not from solid studies by those in medical or insurance fields or even the U.S. government, but from “an economic historian at the University of Munich.” And that is not noted until the 11th paragraph of the 29-paragraph story.
• No details on how the information was pinpointed other than the source “has spent the last quarter century compiling data on heights of nations.”
• Strangest of all is nowhere in the lengthy piece are actual height comparison numbers indicated for current and past Americans. An accompanying, though not precise, chart (distributed by AP) shows average height of U.S. white males grew 2 inches from the 1800s to 2000 while U.S. black men grew 3.5 inches in the same period. This, according to the chart, compares with the Netherlands which has seen 7.5 inches’ growth in the period while the story declares “even residents of the former communist East Germany are taller than Americans today.”
• No mention is made that the suspected lower growth trend in U.S. residents’ height may be attributed to the influx in recent decades of smaller-size immigrants from Mexico, Asia, Central America and South America.
• Universal health care coverage in Europe is mentioned toward the end of the story plus the sentence: “In the United States, by comparison, an estimated 9 million children have no health insurance.”
Hmmm.
